We've been in the habit of eating Jif peanut butter for the past few years at the Hammond house. I've never been too picky about brands - my only distinction is: the crunchier the better!
Recently, several of my coworkers have mentioned that Skippy Natural is the BEST peanut butter (interestingly enough, the topic of peanut butter has come up on several occasions in the workplace).
Andie and I tried it and completely agreed! Skippy Natural is really good - nutty and delicious!! So, we made the switch. Hello Skippy, goodbye Jif.
Then, several weeks ago, Andie came upon an article in Consumer Reports rating the best peanut butters. Of course, we had to read up and do a taste test on their number one. According to the magazine, the best peanut butter is... (drumroll, please...) Smucker's Organic.
So, I bought it (and I had a coupon - score!).
And I tried it.
It was good.
I don't know if it was great, though. I still had Skippy on my mind. The Smuckers was, for lack of a better way to describe it, kind-of dry tasting. I don't even know if that makes sense, but with Skippy I just wanted to grab the biggest spoon I could find and dive right in. With Smuckers, it just tasted like spreadable dry roasted nuts. It lacked pizzaz. It lacked personality.
Clearly though, other "consumers" do not share my opinion.
Now, this is where my real problem starts. So, after the initial tasting is complete, I look on the side of the label for instructions about storage. We don't typically buy the peanut butter that requires stirring, so I wanted to make sure that I followed the directions.

I see at the top right it says "Oil Separation is Natural. Just Stir & Refrigerate".
So, that's what I did.
When it was time for my next PB&J (days later), I opened up the jar to find a crumbly mess!

This was not spreadable!
The cold peanut butter could not be stirred - it was just hard and crumbly! Was I supposed to microwave it for a few seconds? Surely heating and cooling the jar every time you wanted a sandwich was not the answer. Was I supposed to let it sit out on the counter for an hour before I made my sandwich? I don't have that kind of time when I'm trying to make lunch in the morning and get out the door as fast as I can!
So, Smuckers Organic, our short-lived relationship must end here. You just don't fit my lifestyle. I'm welcoming back my dear friend, Skippy Natural. He has been greatly missed.